Private trees
Private trees that are removed must be replaced, either through replanting trees, or cash-in-lieu of replacement or a combination of the two. The total amount of replacement trees is based on the tree size removed. Refer to the table below to determine how many trees you will be required to plant.
Trunk Diameter (DBH) of the Tree Removed | Compensation Ratio |
20 – 35 cm | 2:1 |
36 – 74 cm | 3:1 |
Greater than or equal to 75 cm | 4:1 |
Replacement trees for private tree removals must be planted within a year of permit issuance or as identified on the tree permit. Replacement trees must be able to grow to a minimum of 4.5 m height at maturity.
When considering which species of trees to replant you must first consider what tree type you are removing. One of your replacement trees must be a similar species to the tree removed. For example, if you remove a deciduous (broadleaf) tree, one of your replacement trees must also be a deciduous (broadleaf) tree.
If opting to replant, there will be a replacement tree security deposit required at the time of your application. Once the trees have been replanted and verified by staff, the deposit will be refunded. The replacement tree security deposit is calculated based on the number of replacement trees required, as it is a deposit per required replacement tree. Refer to the table above to determine the number of replacement trees required and the tree permit fees and securities section of the webpage for the fee and security information.
Replacement trees shall be planted on your private property and not on a property line unless consent from your neighbour was given in compliance with the Forestry Act.
Replacement trees can also be planted on another private lot within the City’s Urban Boundary as approved by staff. If planting on an alternate lot, that lot will need to be identified on the tree replacement plan and we require a letter from the owner of that lot indicating this acceptance. The permit holder will be responsible for paying the tree replacement security deposit, and ensuring the trees are planted. The permit holder will be responsible for notifying staff once the trees are planted to get their deposit refunded. Deposits will only be refunded to the payee of the deposit.
Replacement trees must be maintained in healthy condition.
Replacement trees must be the following minimum sizes at the time of installation:
- 30 mm caliper if deciduous (broadleaf)
- 125 cm tall if coniferous (evergreen)
Trees must be tree-form species that achieve a mature height of at least 4.5 m and contribute to long-term urban canopy cover. Dwarf, weeping, top-grafted ornamental, and shrub-form varieties do not qualify.
If there is no room for the replacement trees on your private lot or you opt to not replant, there will be a cash-in-lieu fee per required replacement tree. Refer to the table above to determine the number of replacement trees required and the tree permit fees and securities section of the webpage for the fee and security information. This money will be used toward the planting of trees elsewhere within the City.
Combinations of replacement trees and cash-in-lieu payment is also permitted to meet your tree replacement requirements for private tree removals.
There is no requirement to replant trees where a tree injury permit is issued.
Example: Tree removed has a DBH measurement of 30cm. This will require two replacement trees: Tree Security Deposit = 2 X "Replacement Tree Security Deposit ($)". Once the trees are planted the security deposit will be refunded.
Public trees
Public tree compensation is to be assessed using the Trunk Formula Technique (TFT), specifically the Reproduction Cost Method, in accordance with the Council of Tree & Landscape Appraisers’ Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th Edition. This nationally recognized methodology determines a tree’s value based on trunk size and applicable depreciation factors, including condition, functional limitations (such as overhead utilities), and external influences (such as pests or site constraints). The calculated value is then evaluated using a unit cost representing the purchase price of the same species from a nursery.
Unit costs are to be derived from the Regional Plant Appraisal Committee (RPAC) Supplemental Guide (2021) to the 10th Edition. When a specific species is not listed, the corresponding genus will be used. If neither the species nor genus appears in the supplemental guide, City staff will be consulted to determine an appropriate unit cost. To obtain a copy of the RPAC supplement, please visit the International Society of Arboriculture Ontario Chapter webpage for more information and to download a copy.
Appraisal submissions will be reviewed by staff as part of the evaluation process. Final determinations regarding compensation are made by the City.